Opens in a new tab

ASTM A691 vs ASTM A672: Key Differences in EFW Steel Pipe

ASTM A691 and ASTM A672 both cover electric-fusion-welded (EFW) steel pipe manufactured with filler metal added from pressure-vessel-quality plate. Their principal distinction is the intended service range and material scope: ASTM A691 covers carbon and alloy steel pipe for high-pressure service at high temperatures, while ASTM A672 covers EFW carbon-steel pipe for high-pressure service at moderate temperatures. The correct specification must be selected against the design conditions, governing code and project requirements.

A671 CC65 C12 11 1 scaledA671 CC65 C12 1 scaled

What ASTM A691 Covers

ASTM A691/A691M covers carbon and alloy steel pipe made by electric-fusion welding with filler metal added. The pipe is fabricated from pressure-vessel-quality plate of several chemical analyses and strength levels and is intended for high-pressure service at high temperatures. The grade identifies the plate type, and the class identifies the pipe heat treatment, radiographic examination and pressure-test requirements.

For Cr-Mo applications, the relevant plate grades include ASTM A387/A387M alloy-steel plate grades. The exact grade and class must be specified; ‘ASTM A691’ alone does not fully define the ordered material.

What ASTM A672 Covers

ASTM A672/A672M covers EFW steel pipe made from pressure-vessel-quality carbon-steel plate for high-pressure service at moderate temperatures. The standard includes multiple plate grades and classes. The required plate grade must be selected from the applicable standard tables and project specification; ASTM A516 is not a universal plate requirement for every A672 grade.

As with A691, the standard designation alone does not establish the design pressure of the completed piping system. Design calculations and material suitability must be evaluated under the governing construction code and project conditions.

Where ASTM A671 Fits

ASTM A671/A671M covers EFW steel pipe for atmospheric and lower-temperature service. It should not be reduced to a simple ‘cold-weather’ category. A671, A672 and A691 distinguish service conditions through their respective scopes; the engineer must evaluate the actual design temperature, pressure, material grade, toughness requirements and applicable code.

A691 vs A672: Side-by-Side Comparison

 
Item ASTM A691/A691M ASTM A672/A672M
Manufacturing Electric-fusion-welded; filler metal added Electric-fusion-welded; filler metal added
Material scope Carbon and alloy steel pressure-vessel-quality plate Carbon-steel pressure-vessel-quality plate
Intended service High-pressure service at high temperatures High-pressure service at moderate temperatures
Grade designation Grade identifies the plate type Grade identifies the plate type
Class designation Defines heat treatment, radiography and pressure-test requirements Defines class-specific manufacturing and test requirements; consult the A672 class table
Selection basis Design conditions, alloy requirements, code and project specification Design conditions, carbon-steel suitability, code and project specification

Both standards use EFW manufacturing, but they are not interchangeable. The choice is not determined by a simple temperature label or by increasing wall thickness. Material allowable stress, design temperature, joint factors, wall-thickness calculations, corrosion allowance and other code requirements must be evaluated for the actual system.

Understanding Grade and Class

For ASTM A691, grade identifies the plate material and class identifies the pipe heat treatment, radiographic examination and pressure testing. For ASTM A672, use the grade and class tables in the applicable edition of A672/A672M; do not transfer an A691 class interpretation to A672 without checking the A672 requirements.

A purchase order should state the full standard designation and edition, grade, class, dimensions and inspection requirements. For example, the A691 designation should include the specified Cr-Mo grade and class rather than only the alloy shorthand.

EFW Compared with Seamless and Other Welded Pipe

EFW and Seamless Pipe

ASTM A691 EFW pipe is manufactured from plate and includes a longitudinal welded joint. ASTM A335, by contrast, covers seamless ferritic alloy-steel pipe for high-temperature service. The manufacturing route, material specification, available dimensions and project requirements should be considered together. Neither product should be described as universally superior; selection requires engineering review.

EFW, ERW and Line Pipe Specifications

EFW, electric-resistance welding (ERW) and other welded-pipe processes are distinct manufacturing routes. ASTM A53, API 5L and ISO 3183 are product specifications with their own permitted manufacturing methods and requirements; they should not be equated with one single welding process. Select the applicable product standard based on the service, material, manufacturing method and governing project specification.

Design Conditions and Dimensions

The governing piping code and design specification determine the design method and allowable material stresses. Important inputs include design pressure, design temperature, outside diameter, wall thickness, material grade, weld-joint considerations, corrosion allowance, external loads and other applicable factors. A larger wall thickness does not automatically compensate for an unsuitable material grade or an inadequate allowable stress at the design temperature.

LONGMA’s stated product range for the relevant large-diameter round pipe category is 406.4–1422.2 mm (16–56 in.) outside diameter, 7.92–75 mm wall thickness and 3–18 m length. These are company-stated product dimensions, not a general dimensional limit for every pipe covered by ASTM A691 or ASTM A672. Confirm the dimensions and manufacturing feasibility for each order.

Testing and Documentation

Define the required examinations and tests before production. ASTM A691 and A672 each contain class-specific requirements; the class table in the relevant standard must be followed. Additional NDE, impact testing, hardness testing, third-party inspection or supplementary requirements should be included in the purchase order when required by the project or governing code.

The documentation package may include heat-specific material test reports, heat-treatment records, NDE reports, pressure-test results, dimensional inspection records and traceability information. Specify the required certificate type, report format, acceptance criteria and any witness or hold points in the inquiry and purchase order.

How to Specify the Correct Standard

Before requesting a quotation, confirm the design pressure and temperature, process fluid, material requirements, governing construction code, applicable ASTM edition, grade, class, dimensions, end preparation, inspection scope and documentation. For lower-temperature service, evaluate the required toughness and the scope of ASTM A671 where relevant. For moderate-temperature high-pressure service, assess ASTM A672. For high-temperature high-pressure service requiring carbon or alloy steel EFW pipe, assess ASTM A691.

The final selection belongs to the responsible design engineer and must satisfy the applicable code and owner specification. A supplier can review the stated product requirements, but a quotation should not replace engineering approval.

LONGMA Round EFW and LSAW Pipe

LONGMA manufactures round ERW and LSAW steel pipes and does not manufacture square or rectangular hollow sections. Its stated factory area is 230,000 m², and annual output exceeds 500,000 tonnes. For an inquiry involving ASTM A691 or another pipe specification, provide the complete material designation, dimensions, test requirements and project conditions so that product scope and manufacturing feasibility can be reviewed.

Conclusion

ASTM A691 and ASTM A672 share the EFW manufacturing route but address different material and service scopes. A691 covers carbon and alloy steel pipe for high-pressure, high-temperature service; A672 covers EFW carbon-steel pipe for high-pressure service at moderate temperatures. ASTM A671 addresses atmospheric and lower-temperature service. Correct selection requires review of the applicable standard edition, grade, class, design conditions, construction code and project requirements.

FAQs

What is the main difference between ASTM A691 and ASTM A672?

Both cover EFW pipe with filler metal added. A691 covers carbon and alloy steel pipe for high-pressure service at high temperatures, while A672 covers EFW carbon-steel pipe for high-pressure service at moderate temperatures.

Are ASTM A691 and ASTM A672 both welded-pipe standards?

Yes. Both cover electric-fusion-welded pipe manufactured with filler metal added. Their material scopes and intended service conditions differ.

Does ASTM A672 always use ASTM A516 plate?

No. A672 includes multiple grades. The required plate grade must be selected from the applicable A672/A672M tables and the project specification.

Is ASTM A671 only for cold-weather service?

Its stated scope is EFW steel pipe for atmospheric and lower temperatures. Actual suitability depends on the specified grade, toughness requirements, design conditions and applicable code.

Can ASTM A691 replace ASTM A335?

Not automatically. A691 covers EFW pipe made from plate, while A335 covers seamless ferritic alloy-steel pipe for high-temperature service. Any substitution requires engineering and code review.

Request a Pipe Specification Review

Send the required standard and edition, grade, class, dimensions, design conditions, inspection requirements and delivery destination to info@ilongma.com. LONGMA can review the inquiry against its round-pipe product scope and provide the relevant manufacturing and quotation information.

Categories

Get Free Quote

Related Article​

Wechat ID: 008618661500134

Request Free Quote